Should I use DFVC or ask for reasonable cause?
Short answer: if the DOL hasn't contacted you in writing, DFVC is usually the cheaper and more predictable route. The penalty is capped, at $1,500 per small plan, and you know the amount before you pay. A reasonable-cause request means filing outside DFVC and waiting for the DOL to propose a penalty, which can run to $2,739 a day, before you argue it down. Choose it only if you have strong, documented reasons for the delay or DFVC is no longer available.
Side by side
| DFVC | Reasonable-cause statement (DOL) | |
|---|---|---|
| Available when | Before the DOL notifies you in writing of the failure to file | After the DOL serves a Notice of Intent to Assess a Penalty |
| Cost | $10/day, capped at $750 per filing and $1,500 per plan (small); $2,000 / $4,000 (large) | Whatever the DOL assesses after review, up to the statutory maximum of $2,739/day |
| Can you argue reasonable cause? | No: paying waives the right to a notice of assessment and to contest the amount (FAQ 20) | Yes, in writing within 30 days of service, signed under penalty of perjury |
| Certainty | You calculate the amount yourself | Unknown until the DOL decides |
| IRS penalties | The IRS generally waives its penalties for plans that complete DFVC | Separate. You'd deal with any IRS penalty on its own terms |
Sources: DFVC FAQs 2, 4, 8, 20 and 21; 29 CFR 2560.502c-2; IRS DFVC relief page.
How the reasonable-cause process works
- The DOL sends a Notice of Intent to Assess stating the amount, the period and the reasons (2560.502c-2(c)).
- You have 30 days from service to file a written statement giving all the facts you rely on, with a declaration that it's made under penalties of perjury (paragraph (e)). Five days are added if the notice came by certified mail (paragraph (i)).
- No penalty accrues from the date the notice is served until the day after the DOL serves its determination (paragraph (b)(2)).
- The DOL issues a written determination. It becomes a final order 45 days after service unless you request a hearing and file an answer within 30 days (paragraphs (g) and (h)).
- If you don't respond to the original notice within 30 days, you're treated as having admitted the facts, and the notice becomes final 45 days after service (paragraph (f)).
What counts as reasonable cause?
The DOL regulation allows a reduction for "mitigating circumstances regarding the degree or willfulness of the noncompliance" and doesn't give a checklist. The IRS's general reasonable-cause guidance is a useful benchmark:
- May qualify: fire, casualty or natural disaster; inability to get records; death or serious illness; system or other circumstances outside your control.
- Generally doesn't qualify on its own: relying on a tax professional, not knowing the requirement, mistakes, or lack of funds.
"Our TPA dropped it" is the most common story and, on that guidance, a weak one.
Worked comparison
A small plan files one year 400 days late.
| Route | Penalty |
|---|---|
| DFVC | $750 (400 × $10 = $4,000, capped at $750 per filing) |
| Outside DFVC, DOL's stated practice for late filers (FAQ 8) | 400 × $50 = $20,000 before any reasonable-cause reduction |
A reasonable-cause request would have to cut the assessment by more than 96% to beat DFVC.
For solo plans
5500-EZ filers can't use DFVC. Before the IRS assesses a penalty, the IRS late-filer program ($500 per return) plays the same role. After a CP283, reasonable cause, by a signed statement or Form 843, is the main route left.
Related questions
Can I use DFVC and still ask for a reasonable-cause waiver?
No. DFVC FAQ 20 says paying the DFVC penalty waives your right to a notice of assessment and to contest the amount. If you want to argue reasonable cause, file outside DFVC and respond to the DOL's notice instead.
Is relying on my accountant or TPA reasonable cause?
Usually not. The IRS says reliance on a tax professional, lack of knowledge, and mistakes generally don't qualify on their own. Fires, natural disasters, serious illness or death, and being unable to get records are examples that may.
Check your own plan
Enter your EIN: we find your plan's filings in the DOL data, list the late years, and compute your program penalty free. $449 for the full Word kit.
Keep reading
Sources
- DOL EBSA: Frequently Asked Questions about the DFVC Program (PDF, Jan. 27, 2020)
- 29 CFR 2560.502c-2: Civil penalties under ERISA 502(c)(2)
- IRS: Penalty relief for reasonable cause
- IRS: Understanding your CP283 notice
- IRS Notice 2014-35 (IRS penalty relief for DFVC filers)
Figures checked against these sources on Nov 15, 2026. Rules and forms change each year; the current IRS and DOL instructions control. All guides.